With skinny jeans, these boots fit perfectly snug. The heel is the same height as a pair of AT perfect pumps, but the thickness makes it more comfortable and stable to walk in. My only complaint is the shaft height... which comes right at the bottom of my knee. I love tall boots, but these may be just a little too tall. The problem is solved by scrunching them down a bit at the ankle, and I'm hoping they won't be as stiff after a few wears. You can see below how high they come up on my calves.
The verdict: Keep. I think $150 for all-leather Ann Taylor boots that are originally $350 is a great deal. They're comfortable, and the shaft height is only a small problem. However, if you are any shorter than I am, which is about 5' 2.5", these will be much too tall for you! Unless over-the-knee boots is your thing. These aren't the perfect pair of high heel boots, but they're pretty good for a first time owner like me!
Has anyone else found their absolute perfect pair of boots yet? Please share!!
Have a great week everyone!